
CRT vs. GRAT: Which Trust Strategy Best Fits Your Estate Plan?
Introduction
Every dollar above the federal exemption can lose 40 cents to estate tax. The right trust may help keep more of that in your family or direct it to a cause you care about. Two of the tools families often compare are a charitable remainder trust (CRT) and a grantor retained annuity trust (GRAT).
The choice comes down to what you want your assets to do. A CRT pays you income for a set period, then leaves what remains to charity. A GRAT can move future growth to your family with little or no gift tax if the assets outperform an IRS benchmark rate and you survive the trust term.
As of 2026, the federal estate and gift tax exemption is $15 million per individual ($30 million for married couples) under IRC § 2010(c)(3), as amended by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in July 2025. The amount adjusts for inflation each year after 2026. The earlier scheduled sunset to roughly $7 million per person no longer applies under current law. Amounts above the exemption are taxed at a top federal rate of 40%. Both trusts can help shrink your taxable estate, so the right pick depends on whether your priority is income and giving or passing wealth to your heirs.
For Florida residents: Florida has no state estate tax or inheritance tax. This is a significant planning advantage compared with residents of states that impose their own estate taxes. Florida residents generally face only federal estate tax exposure, although property located in a state with its own estate tax can still be taxed there.
While CRTs focus on personal income and philanthropy, GRATs prioritize moving significant growth to the next generation.
Key Takeaways
- Tax efficiency: Both strategies can move value out of your taxable estate, but in different ways. CRT assets are generally still included in the grantor's gross estate when the grantor keeps the payment stream for life (IRC § 2036), but the estate tax charitable deduction (IRC § 2055) offsets the value passing to charity, so those assets usually bear little or no estate tax. GRATs only remove appreciation above the Section 7520 rate; if the grantor dies during the GRAT term, all or most of the GRAT's value is generally pulled back into the taxable estate under IRC § 2036 and Treas. Reg. § 20.2036-1(c)(2).
- Income vs. growth: CRTs provide a steady income stream. GRATs are designed to pass rapid asset appreciation to your heirs.
- Philanthropy: A CRT serves your charitable goals. A GRAT is strictly a family wealth transfer vehicle.
- Rate environment: The Section 7520 rate directly affects GRAT results and CRT charitable deductions. Lower 7520 rates favor GRATs because the hurdle is easier to beat. Higher rates favor CRTs, particularly annuity trusts (CRATs), because they produce larger charitable deductions. The rate is set under IRC § 7520 and Treas. Reg. §§ 1.7520-1 through 1.7520-4; at 6.2% for November 2026 (Rev. Rul. 2026-21), it sits near the middle of its historical range.
What Are Split-Interest Trusts and How Do They Work?
A split-interest trust divides ownership of assets into two parts: the income interest and the remainder interest. You, as the grantor, generally keep the right to receive payments for a set period. When that period ends, whatever is left (the remainder) passes to your chosen beneficiary.
To secure significant tax benefits, these trusts must be irrevocable, so you cannot easily change your mind once the assets are moved. The IRS uses the Section 7520 rate to value the two interests. That valuation determines how much of the transfer counts as a taxable gift versus a return to you.
Why the rate matters: the 7520 rate sets the present value of the income and remainder interests, so the same trust produces very different numbers depending on when it is created. The illustrative figures below compare the November 2026 rate of 6.2% with a 2.0% rate.
Figures are simplified illustrations that assume year-end payments; actual results use the IRS tables and your trust's specific terms.
The IRS publishes the actuarial tables that must be used to value split-interest transfers in the Treasury Regulations under IRC § 7520. For readers who want the technical detail, see Treas. Reg. §§ 1.7520-1 through 1.7520-4.
What Is a Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT)?
A CRT lets you convert highly appreciated assets into an income stream while supporting a cause you care about. It balances personal financial security with philanthropy.
How a CRT Works (Step by Step)
- Fund the trust. You transfer appreciated assets, such as stock or real estate, into the CRT.
- Sell without trust-level capital gains tax. Because the trust is tax-exempt, the trustee can sell those assets without paying capital gains tax at the trust level.
- Receive payments. You choose a fixed annual payment (a charitable remainder annuity trust, or CRAT) or a payment equal to a fixed percentage of the trust's value each year (a charitable remainder unitrust, or CRUT).
- Charity receives the remainder. When the term ends or the last income beneficiary dies, the remaining assets go to the qualified charity you chose.
Tax-exempt does not mean tax-free. CRTs are tax-exempt under IRC § 664, and the trust itself pays no capital gains tax on asset sales. But beneficiaries pay income tax on distributions under a four-tier system: ordinary income first, then capital gains, then other (including tax-exempt) income, then return of principal (IRC § 664(b); Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(d)). The practical effect is that your gain is spread over years of payments rather than taxed all at once.
CRUT variations offer added flexibility, particularly for pre-retirement planning and younger clients. Each has distinct advantages depending on when you need liquidity:
- NICRUT (net income CRUT): pays the lesser of the unitrust amount or the trust's actual net income.
- NIMCRUT (net income with makeup CRUT): works like a NICRUT, but shortfalls are tracked and can be paid in later years when income exceeds the unitrust amount.
- FLIPCRUT: starts as a net income CRUT and converts to a standard unitrust upon a triggering event, such as the sale of real estate or reaching a set date.
Payout rate limits: annual payouts must be at least 5% and no more than 50%, and the present value of the charitable remainder must be at least 10% of the trust's initial fair market value (IRC § 664(d)(1)(D) and § 664(d)(2)(D)). In practice, many CRTs use payout rates of 5% to 8% to increase the charitable deduction and help satisfy the 10% remainder test.
Key Tax Benefits of a CRT
You receive an immediate income tax deduction based on the present value of the future gift to charity. And because the trust can sell without trust-level capital gains tax, 100% of the sale proceeds stay invested.
The charitable deduction is subject to adjusted gross income (AGI) limits under IRC § 170(b). For cash contributions to public charities, the limit is 60% of AGI; for long-term appreciated property, it is generally 30% of AGI. If the remainder can pass to a private foundation, lower limits apply and the deduction for assets other than publicly traded stock may be limited to your cost basis. Excess deductions can be carried forward for five years (IRC § 170(b)(1)(C), (D), and (G); § 170(d)(1); § 170(e)(1)(B)(ii)). Starting in 2026, itemized charitable deductions also face a 0.5%-of-AGI floor, and the tax benefit of itemized deductions is capped at 35% for taxpayers in the top bracket.
Beyond income tax, assets that pass to charity through the trust generally escape estate tax, because your estate receives a charitable deduction for them (IRC § 2055). The federal estate tax rate is currently 40% on amounts exceeding the exemption. Florida has no state estate tax. For a family above the exemption, every $1 million moved out of the estate can avoid up to $400,000 in federal estate tax.
CRT Pros and Cons
The advantages are significant: lifetime income, the ability to diversify a concentrated position, and a lasting philanthropic legacy. The trade-offs are real too. The charity's remainder interest must be worth at least 10% of the trust's initial value when the trust is funded (an actuarial test, not a guaranteed amount), and whatever remains at the end goes to charity, so your heirs will not receive the principal. And these trusts require professional administration to stay compliant.
Administration costs should be quantified. Typical ongoing costs include trustee fees (often 0.5% to 1.5% annually), tax preparation fees, investment management fees, and legal and compliance costs. These expenses can significantly reduce net returns, particularly for smaller CRTs. Many practitioners recommend minimum funding of $500,000 to $1 million to justify setup and ongoing costs.
Who Should Consider a CRT?
- Tech executives with concentrated, low-basis stock positions they want to diversify
- Real estate investors holding highly appreciated property
- Business owners planning an exit, if the trust is funded before a sale is practically certain to close (otherwise the gain can be taxed to the owner) and the business is not an S corporation, whose stock a CRT generally cannot hold
- Retirees seeking diversification and income without an upfront capital gains hit
What Is a Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT)?
A GRAT is an estate freeze strategy designed to shift rapid asset growth to your heirs with little or no gift tax cost.
How a GRAT Works (Step by Step)
You transfer high-growth assets into an irrevocable trust for a fixed term, often two to five years. In return, the trust pays you a fixed annual annuity. Together, the payments return your original principal plus a return equal to the IRS hurdle rate.
Most planners use a zeroed-out structure. The present value of the annuity stream, discounted at the Section 7520 rate, equals the fair market value of the assets contributed. This creates a remainder interest valued at or near zero for gift tax purposes. If the assets appreciate above the 7520 hurdle rate, the excess passes to beneficiaries free of gift tax.
Hypothetical example: a $1 million contribution at a 6.2% Section 7520 rate (November 2026) with a 2-year term requires an annual annuity payment of approximately $547,000. If the assets grow at 15% per year, approximately $147,000 passes to beneficiaries free of gift tax.
Legislative risk: the zeroed-out GRAT has been in Congress's crosshairs for years. Past proposals, including in prior budget proposals, have sought to impose minimum GRAT terms (for example, 10 years), minimum remainder values (for example, 25% or more of contributed assets), or a prohibition on decreasing annuities. None has passed as of publication, and the 2025 tax law left GRATs unchanged. GRATs remain effective under current law, but you and your advisors should monitor potential reforms.
Why GRATs Excel for Appreciating Assets
The key to a successful GRAT is the Section 7520 hurdle rate. If the trust's assets grow faster than this rate, the excess passes to your beneficiaries free of gift tax. That makes GRATs well suited to volatile or high-upside assets such as pre-IPO shares, private equity, or concentrated tech stock.
The rate is 6.2% for November 2026 (Rev. Rul. 2026-21); verify and use the most current rate as of your funding date. The IRS publishes the 7520 rate monthly in Revenue Rulings. It equals 120% of the applicable federal midterm rate, rounded to the nearest 0.2% (IRC § 7520(a)). For transfers that qualify for a charitable deduction, such as a CRT, the grantor may elect to use the rate from either of the two months before the transfer month.
Rolling GRATs
Many investors use rolling GRATs to capture short-term market gains. Each annuity payment you receive is used to fund a new short-term GRAT. A strong year gets locked in by one trust, and a later downturn affects only the trusts funded afterward.
GRAT Pros and Cons
The biggest advantage of a GRAT is the ability to transfer substantial value to your family with little or no use of your lifetime exemption. The 2026 federal gift and estate tax exemption is $15 million per individual ($30 million per married couple) under IRC § 2010(c)(3), as amended in July 2025, and is indexed for inflation in later years.
It is often called a "heads you win, tails you don't lose" strategy. If the assets underperform the hurdle rate, you get your assets back through the annuity, and you are mainly out the setup costs. The label is shorthand, not a guarantee: it assumes you survive the term and the assets were valued correctly.
GRATs do have trade-offs. Unlike a CRT, a GRAT provides no income tax deduction, and you pay income tax on the trust's earnings during the term. That is because GRATs are grantor trusts under IRC §§ 671–679. Paying the tax is actually a benefit: it lets the trust assets grow without income tax erosion, effectively making additional tax-free gifts to your beneficiaries. You do not receive a gift tax deduction for paying these taxes, and under Rev. Rul. 2004-64 the payment is not treated as a taxable gift. This "tax burn" feature can make a GRAT more effective.
The primary risk is mortality. If the grantor dies during the GRAT term, IRC § 2036(a) pulls back into the gross estate the portion of the trust needed to produce the retained annuity, which for a short-term GRAT is usually all of it (Treas. Reg. § 20.2036-1(c)(2)). This generally eliminates the estate tax benefit. It is why shorter GRAT terms (2–5 years) are strongly preferred, especially for older grantors or those with health concerns, and why actuarial life expectancy should inform the choice of term.
CRT vs. GRAT Comparison Table
Which Strategy Is Right for Your Estate?
The choice depends on whether you want to support a cause or maximize what stays in the family. Both are effective, but they solve different problems within an estate plan.
Choose a CRT If…
You hold highly appreciated assets and want to avoid an immediate capital gains bill. If charitable giving is central to your legacy, a CRT lets you fulfill that mission while securing an income stream for yourself or your spouse.
Hypothetical example: Sarah, age 62, holds $3 million of publicly traded stock with a $200,000 basis. She wants to diversify, support her alma mater, and generate retirement income. A CRUT lets the trust sell the stock without trust-level capital gains tax, gives her an immediate charitable deduction (the amount depends on her age and the payout rate), and pays her annual distributions for life.
Choose a GRAT If…
You own assets expected to appreciate significantly over a short window, such as pre-IPO shares or founder's stock, and your priority is transferring wealth to family while using little of your lifetime exemption. Because of mortality risk, a GRAT works best if you are in good health and expect to outlive the term.
Hypothetical example: Robert, age 55 and in excellent health, owns $5 million of pre-IPO stock in a company expected to go public within two years. He funds a 2-year zeroed-out GRAT at the November 2026 rate of 6.2%, which requires annuity payments of about $2.73 million per year. If the stock is flat in year one and triples after the IPO in year two, roughly $4.1 million passes to his children free of gift tax, assuming he survives the term. This illustration is not a prediction; if the stock does not outperform the 7520 rate, nothing passes to his children.
When to Use Both
A barbell strategy may be appropriate for an estate large enough to have both charitable intent and intergenerational wealth transfer goals. Consider it for estates approaching or exceeding the 2026 exemption ($15 million per individual / $30 million per married couple). Depending on state of residence and family situation, it may make sense well below that level.
A CRT can provide your own income and reduce current income taxes, while layered GRATs can capture future growth for your heirs. The CRT handles the present and your charitable legacy; the GRAT handles the next generation.
For example, a married couple with a $40 million estate is about $10 million over the combined exemption. If a mix of CRT funding and successful GRATs keeps $10 million of value out of the taxable estate, the federal estate tax avoided at 40% is about $4 million.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Setting and forgetting your plan
A strategy that worked when rates were low may underperform when rates climb, so active monitoring matters. The Section 7520 rate has fluctuated significantly over the past few decades, from highs above 8% in the 1990s to lows under 1% in 2020–2021. At 6.2% for November 2026, the current environment sits within that range and well above the 2020–2021 lows. Rising rates increase charitable deductions for annuity-style CRTs (CRATs) but make GRATs less effective, because the hurdle is harder to beat. Falling rates have the opposite effect. If you have existing structures, review them annually to decide whether new structures make sense at current rates.
Inaccurate valuations
Misvaluing private assets can trigger IRS audits and penalties: undervaluation is the risk with a GRAT, and overvaluation is the risk with a CRT deduction. For private company stock, real estate, and other hard-to-value assets contributed to GRATs or CRTs, grantors generally must obtain qualified appraisals under IRC § 170(f)(11) and Treas. Reg. §§ 1.170A-16 and 1.170A-17 (for CRT contributions above the appraisal thresholds, other than publicly traded securities) and follow the general gift tax valuation rules under IRC § 2512 and Treas. Reg. § 25.2512-1 (for GRATs). A valuation misstatement can trigger IRC § 6662 accuracy-related penalties (20%, or 40% for a gross misstatement) or even IRC § 6663 civil fraud penalties (75%). The IRS frequently challenges valuations in GRAT audits, so a qualified appraisal and a defensible valuation methodology are essential (see, for example, Chief Counsel Advice 202152018, in which the IRS treated a GRAT funded with undervalued shares as failing to qualify and the full contribution as a taxable gift).
Planning without the right team
The most important safeguard is working with qualified estate planning attorneys, CPAs, and financial advisors who use sophisticated modeling tools, such as estate planning software, financial modeling tools, and tax projection software. These tools help test funding amounts and timing against market and rate scenarios, but they supplement, and do not replace, professional judgment and legal and tax advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
CRT Questions
How does a charitable remainder trust work?
A CRT works in three phases. You fund the trust, typically with highly appreciated assets. The trust pays you income for a term of up to 20 years or for life. When the term ends, the remaining assets go to a qualified charity. For CRATs, the annuity must be at least 5% but not more than 50% of the initial fair market value of the trust assets (IRC § 664(d)(1)(A)). For CRUTs, the annual payout must be at least 5% but not more than 50% of the net fair market value of trust assets, valued annually (IRC § 664(d)(2)(A)). Both are subject to the 10% minimum remainder requirement. The practical payout range is typically 5% to 8%.
Do charitable remainder trusts pay capital gains tax?
Not at the trust level. The CRT is tax-exempt and pays no capital gains tax when it sells assets, so the full proceeds can be reinvested. One exception: a CRT owes a 100% excise tax on any unrelated business taxable income (IRC § 664(c)(2)), which can arise from debt-financed property or operating business interests. But beneficiaries pay tax on distributions under the four-tier ordering system of IRC § 664(b): Tier 1 (ordinary income), Tier 2 (capital gains), Tier 3 (other, including tax-exempt, income), Tier 4 (return of corpus). Distributions are taxed in this order until each tier is exhausted (Treas. Reg. § 1.664-1(d)(1)). This means distributions are taxed as ordinary income to the extent the trust has current or undistributed ordinary income, and as capital gain after that, so the gain from a sale is passed out to you over time rather than eliminated.
What happens if the charity I name no longer exists?
A well-drafted CRT names alternate charities or gives the trustee power to select another qualified charity. If the named charity no longer exists or no longer qualifies when the remainder is distributed, the assets go to the alternate.
GRAT Questions
Who pays taxes on a grantor retained annuity trust?
The grantor. While this may seem like a burden, paying the tax personally lets the trust assets compound for your heirs without being depleted. The characterization of the annuity payment itself is more complex than "not taxable." Because a GRAT is a grantor trust, you report all trust income on your personal return, whether or not it is distributed, so the tax has already been paid. The annuity payments draw on both principal and trust earnings, depending on what the trust earned and how payments are allocated (Treas. Reg. §§ 1.671-1 through 1.677(a)-1). Under Rev. Rul. 2004-64, your payment of the trust's income tax is not treated as an additional gift.
What happens at the end of a GRAT term?
Any assets remaining in the trust pass to your beneficiaries. You have already received your principal plus the hurdle-rate return through the annuity payments. If the assets did not grow as expected, they come back to you through the annuity, and nothing passes to your heirs. The remainder passes free of gift tax, because the taxable gift was calculated at trust inception based on the present value of the remainder interest, typically zeroed out (IRC § 2702). However, beneficiaries receive a carryover basis in the assets under IRC § 1015, meaning they may owe capital gains tax on your built-in gain when they sell. If you survive the term, the transfer is free of additional gift and estate tax, but not income tax.
What happens to a GRAT if the grantor dies during the term?
The strategy generally fails, which is why many planners use terms of two to five years. Under IRC § 2036(a)(1), all or most of the GRAT assets are generally included in the grantor's estate, measured at date-of-death value rather than the original contribution amount (Treas. Reg. § 20.2036-1(c)(2)). If the assets have appreciated significantly, this can result in substantial estate tax. And the cost is more than the setup fees: the grantor has paid income taxes on trust earnings without achieving the intended wealth transfer. Life insurance can be used to hedge GRAT mortality risk.
Can I use a GRAT if I have health issues?
You can, but mortality risk is higher. A shorter term, a series of short rolling GRATs, or life insurance to cover the potential estate tax can help. Discuss your health and life expectancy openly with your advisors before choosing a term.
Can I name a charity as the remainder beneficiary of a GRAT?
It is permitted but rarely makes sense. GRATs are built for noncharitable remainder beneficiaries, and a charitable remainder in a GRAT does not qualify for an income or gift tax charitable deduction (IRC §§ 170(f)(2)(A), 2522(c)(2)). If charitable giving is a goal, consider a charitable lead annuity trust (CLAT), which reverses the structure: the charity receives annuity payments during the term, and the remainder passes to family. CLATs work best when interest rates are low and can complement a GRAT strategy.
Comparison Questions
Can I change my mind after establishing a CRT or GRAT?
Both are irrevocable. Once funded, you cannot simply undo either trust. GRATs commonly let the grantor substitute assets of equal value, which adds some flexibility.
How do CRTs and GRATs interact with the generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax?
GRATs are generally poor vehicles for passing assets directly to grandchildren. GST exemption cannot be allocated until the GRAT term ends, by which point the remainder may have grown substantially. Most GRATs name children, or a trust for children, as remainder beneficiaries. CRTs rarely raise GST issues because the remainder goes to charity, though naming a grandchild as an income beneficiary can.
Disclosures
This article discusses estate planning strategies that involve complex tax and legal considerations. This article is not legal advice. Readers should consult an attorney before deciding on any trust planning strategy and qualified tax advisors before implementing any strategy discussed herein. The examples in this article are hypothetical illustrations, not predictions or guarantees of any result. Tax laws are subject to change, and the analysis in this article is based on law in effect as of October 2026.
Material prepared herein has been created for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, or investment advice or a recommendation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Information was obtained from sources believed to be reliable but was not verified for accuracy. All advisory services are offered through Savvy Advisors, Inc. (Savvy Advisors), an investment advisor registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
De Paz Law, 12651 Walsingham Road, Suite B, Largo, Florida 33774, is responsible for the legal content of this article.

Hi 👋🏼 I'm Albert. I advise corporate executives, entrepreneurs, and wealth-builders to shift from the noise of managing financial complexity to a state of total clarity, backed by a custom blueprint deliberately aligned with what matters most in life. At our practice, we believe building wealth is just the baseline. Many professionals and business owners reach a threshold where they’ve achieved incredible career milestones, yet find a more profound question emerging: How do I align these resources to live with deep intentionality? We step in as dedicated partners at that exact crossroad, guiding our clients as they streamline their financial moving pieces so they can focus on the experiences, people, and pursuits that give life true meaning. Together, we transform wealth from a complex web of numbers into a protective, highly optimized engine to give you the ultimate freedom to accomplish what really matters today and secure your legacy for tomorrow.





