What to do when the market loses its mind

Markets move in response to new information. That's not a flaw in the system. That's the system working exactly as designed. 

The problem is that sometimes new information arrives in a way that nobody quite knows how to model. A sudden policy change. A geopolitical escalation. A new set of tariffs that could mean three different things depending on how they play out. And when people can't model something cleanly, they tend to do one of two things: freeze, or panic. 

Neither of those is a strategy. 

The irony of volatility 

Here's something I've come to believe after decades in this business: volatility is not your enemy. Volatility is actually a sign of a healthy market, one that is alive, processing information, adjusting. 

What you should actually worry about is a market that doesn't move. A market that only goes up, steadily, with no correction, is a market building toward bubble-like conditions. The volatility you dread is the same mechanism that creates the equity premium, which is the reason stocks, over time, outperform bonds and cash. 

No premium without risk. No risk without volatility. You can't have it both ways. 

That said, knowing that intellectually and experiencing it in your account are two different things. So let's talk about what actually matters when things get turbulent. 

What the predictions miss 

When markets sell off sharply around a specific policy or event (tariffs, a Fed decision, a geopolitical development, whatever the current catalyst happens to be), the prediction machine kicks into high gear. Best-case scenarios. Worst-case scenarios. Confident projections about what happens if X escalates or Y gets resolved.

Here's my honest take on all of that: I don't find it particularly useful. 

Not because the analysis is lazy. But because the variables involved in any of these situations are genuinely too numerous to model well. What I've learned is that markets have eventually bounced back from every single major disruption in modern history. Not always quickly. Not always in a straight line. But eventually. 

That's not blind optimism. That's just the track record. And maintaining that perspective when everything feels uncertain is one of the most valuable things I can offer. 

The part of your portfolio that's actually working right now 

When the headline index is down, the S&P, the Nasdaq, whatever the number is on the screen, the natural instinct is to feel like everything is down. That's rarely true for a thoughtfully constructed portfolio. 

Diversification is one of those words that gets used so often it can start to feel like a platitude. It isn't one. It's a genuine risk management tool, and it's why a well-built portfolio rarely looks exactly like the index during a correction. 

International stocks, particularly small cap international and emerging markets, often move differently than U.S. large cap stocks. Alternative positions, including long/short strategies, can reduce correlation further. Fixed income, when structured correctly with quality and appropriate duration, provides ballast. 

The goal isn't to eliminate volatility from your life. The goal is to make sure that when one part of the market is going sideways, you're not fully exposed to it. 

What we do when others don't know what to do 

Market volatility, frankly, gives us opportunities that a flat market doesn't. 

When prices decline, we look at where we can rebalance, trimming positions that have held up well and adding to positions that have sold off more than their fundamentals warrant. We look at whether tax-loss harvesting makes sense. We evaluate whether any of the fear in the market has created a genuine value opportunity. 

None of this requires predicting what happens next. It requires staying disciplined, staying diversified, and making rational decisions when others are making emotional ones. 

The clients I've worked with who have built real wealth over time share one trait more than any other: they didn't let a bad quarter turn into a bad decade. They stayed the course, made adjustments where it was smart to, and kept their eyes on the actual goal: not a portfolio number, but what that portfolio was eventually going to enable them to do with their lives. 

One thing worth remembering 

I've been in this business for a long time. I've seen multiple recessions, a global pandemic, two significant bear markets, and more "unprecedented" events than I can count. 

Markets always had plenty of reasons to sell off. And they always, eventually, found reasons to recover. 

I can't predict when. But I've stopped believing that timing matters as much as patience. And I've seen enough to know that the clients who did the worst weren't the ones who held through volatility. They were the ones who sold at the bottom and waited for the "all clear" that never quite came clearly enough.

If your portfolio is diversified, if your allocation matches your actual life and goals, and if you're working with someone whose job is to keep you rational when the market isn't, you're probably in better shape than the headlines would have you believe. 

Now go do something better with your time than watching the ticker. 

‍

Chris Benda, Founder, Benda & Co.